42 U.S.C. § 1983 is the primary way in which you can enforce the federal Constitution against state and local officials in Tennessee who would violate your Constitutional rights. Municipalities and municipal entities may also be brought to court pursuant to a Section 1983 action so long as a “final decision maker” acted to violate your rights. Municipalities include cities and counties, and municipal entities include such municipal arms as commissions, schools boards and sheriff departments.
If you have been involved in a Tennessee car wreck with a police officer, been victimized by a public official, or otherwise believe that your Constitutional rights have been violated, the experienced Gatlinburg personal injury lawyers at Baker Associates can help.
There are two threshold “facts” that must be established in any Section 1983 action. First, the defendant must be a “person” that can legally be brought before a court under Section 1983. Second, the defendant had to have acted under “color of state law.” Under the Act, “persons” are not just individuals, but public officials and municipalities. However, states (such as Tennessee) are not “persons” under the Act pursuant to the 11th Amendment of the Constitution. Moreover, a federal official or federal agency is not a person for purposes of the Act; however, a federal official can be sued for violation of a Constitutional right under a so-called Bivens action. With respect to the second element—to act under “color of state law”—the official must have violated a Constitutional right pursuant to a power given to him by the state or municipality.
With the elements of a Section 1983 action in mind, let’s look at the criminal accusations a Rogersville woman recently levied against a Hamblen county employee. On June 2, 2009, a Rogersville, Tennessee, woman testified before a jury that a former Hamblen county Sheriff’s Office Deputy, Dexter L. Morris, raped her in the back of his police cruiser. According to the prosecution, Deputy Morris stopped the victim’s vehicle and ordered her boyfriend to walk home after finding some marijuana. The deputy then allegedly coerced her into having intercourse with him after he threatened her with drug possession charges and getting her fired from her job.
While if proven the defendant may be convicted of criminal rape, he may also be liable to the alleged victim under Section 1983 for costs associated with pain and suffering and psychological treatment. First, the officer is a “person” under the Act because he is a county employee. Second, he allegedly used the power bestowed to him by Hamblen County to force the alleged victim to have sexual relations with him. Thus, under the facts as described, the deputy acted under color of state law to deprive the alleged victim of liberty, due process, and a right to be free from official brutality.
You may be thinking at this point that a sheriff’s deputy would not be able to pay any substantial damages award. Often, however, police officers sign agreements with the state or county to indemnify them if found guilty in a civil action. This means that the state pays, not the officer. If injured, call 866-853-2888 to speak with Tennessee’s skilled personal injury attorneys at Baker Associates for a free consultation.